Utility vs. Enclosed Trailers: Which One Fits Your Needs?
Key Takeaways
Utility and enclosed trailers vary in design, cost, and protection. Your choice depends on cargo type, budget, and how often you plan to haul.
Utility trailers cost less and offer open access
Enclosed trailers secure loads and shield them from the weather
Choose based on cargo size and frequency of use
Match trailer type to long-term hauling needs
Buying a trailer isn’t as simple as it seems. You know you need one, but deciding between a utility trailer and an enclosed trailer can feel like a guessing game. Pick the wrong type and you risk wasting money, damaging cargo, or feeling frustrated every time you haul.
On the flip side, picking the right trailer makes every trip easier. It keeps your cargo safe, fits your budget, and works well with your towing gear. Your decision depends on what you haul, how often you use it, and how much protection you need.
Let’s go over the pros, cons, and best uses so you can make the call with confidence.
Utility Trailers: Pros, Cons, and Ideal Uses
A utility trailer is an open-frame, versatile trailer with no walls or roof. It’s designed for flexibility and ease of use, making it a favorite for hauling equipment, building materials, or recreational gear.
Pros of utility trailers
Lower upfront cost - Utility trailers usually cost less than enclosed trailers, which makes them a good option if you have a tight budget or would like to put more money toward other equipment. That lower entry price means you can own a trailer without taking on a big financial commitment.
Easy loading and unloading - The open design gives you full access from every angle. You can lift heavy boxes over the side, roll ATVs or lawn tractors up a ramp, or slide lumber straight on without fighting tight doorways. A utility trailer makes moving large or bulky items easier and saves time and effort.
Lighter weight - Utility trailers weigh less because they don’t have an enclosed frame. That’s why they’re easier to pull with mid-size trucks or SUVs. Lighter weight also puts less strain on your towing vehicle and can help you save fuel on long trips.
Cons of utility trailers
Cargo exposure - The open bed leaves your load exposed to weather conditions. Rain, wind, or road debris can damage certain items, and you’ll often need to cover cargo with a tarp. Since security is limited, your items are also more at risk of theft.
Limited protection - While sturdy enough for heavy gear, utility trailers aren’t the best choice for fragile or valuable cargo. Delicate tools, electronics, or moisture-sensitive items are at risk without a sealed environment.
Enclosed Trailers: Pros, Cons, and Ideal Uses
An enclosed trailer offers the opposite experience of a utility model. With walls, a roof, and lockable doors, it becomes a secure, weatherproof space on wheels. You can use it as a mobile storage unit or even a workshop on the go. If you need to keep gear safe while in transit, an enclosed trailer gives you peace of mind.
Pros of enclosed trailers
Full cargo protection - Unlike open trailers, enclosed models keep out rain, snow, dust, and road debris. They keep weather-sensitive cargo—such as furniture, appliances, or trade show equipment—safe. You won’t need tarps, and your cargo stays secure even in sudden bad weather.
Added security - Lockable doors mean you can leave tools, motorcycles, or merchandise inside without constant supervision. Enclosed trailers are handy if you’re a contractor carrying valuable equipment or a vendor storing inventory between events.
Customizable storage - You can add shelves, racks, hooks, or tie-down systems to organize your belongings. You can even turn your enclosed trailer into a mobile workshop, vendor booth, or specialized hauler for bikes, cars, or gear.
Cons of enclosed trailers
Higher upfront cost - Enclosed trailers generally cost more than utility trailers, so make sure the benefits fit your needs before buying. If you use one often, the investment usually pays off in protection and convenience, but it’s not always justified for casual hauling.
Heavier weight - The enclosed build adds significant weight, which demands a stronger towing vehicle. Heavier loads also reduce fuel efficiency, so you’ll spend more on gas over time compared to pulling a lighter utility trailer.
More maintenance - Enclosed trailers have more parts to care for, like hinges, locks, seals, and the frame. If you’re used to the simplicity of open trailers, this extra upkeep will be challenging.
Side-By-Side Comparison: Utility vs. Enclosed Trailers
Sometimes the easiest way to decide between utility and enclosed trailers is to look at both options side by side. You should consider the following factors:
Cost
Utility trailers are generally cheaper. Their open design keeps manufacturing simple, which lowers the purchase price. Enclosed trailers cost more upfront, but can deliver long-term value if you need the extra protection and security.
Cargo protection
With a utility trailer, your load is exposed to rain, dust, and theft risk. Meanwhile, enclosed trailers offer weatherproof walls and lockable doors. They’re the safer option for fragile or valuable cargo.
Maintenance
Utility trailers have fewer moving parts, less upkeep, and lower repair costs. Enclosed trailers demand a bit more attention because of their doors, locks, and seals.
Towing requirements
Utility trailers are lighter, so they’re easier to tow with mid-size trucks or SUVs. Enclosed trailers add weight, which often means you’ll need a more powerful vehicle and more fuel.
Usage fit
Utility trailers are great for hauling bulky, rugged loads like landscaping gear, lumber, or recreational equipment. Enclosed trailers excel when you need organization, security, and cargo protection.
How to Decide Which Trailer Fits Your Needs
Choosing between a utility and an enclosed trailer comes down to your situation. Instead of asking which trailer is “better,” think about what you haul, how often you use it, and what your long-term goals look like.
- Cargo type - Are you moving rugged materials like lumber, yard waste, or ATVs? A utility trailer handles those jobs well. For delicate or valuable cargo, an enclosed trailer provides the protection you need.
- Budget - If you want to save money upfront, go with a utility trailer. Enclosed trailers may cost more initially, but if you plan to use them often, the extra investment usually pays off in convenience and security.
- Towing vehicle - Match the trailer to your tow setup. Lighter utility trailers pair well with mid-size trucks and SUVs. Enclosed trailers demand more power, so check your vehicle’s towing capacity before deciding.
- Frequency of use - Occasional hauls for home projects or weekend toys may not justify the expense of an enclosed trailer. If you rely on your trailer daily for business or frequent travel, the added protection is worth it.
- Long-term goals - If you expect to expand your work, take on larger projects, or transport more valuable items over time, investing in an enclosed trailer now can save you from an expensive upgrade later.
Choose With Confidence
The choice between open and enclosed models comes down to how you plan to use your trailer. If you value affordability and versatility, a utility trailer may be the right fit. If security and protection matter more, an enclosed trailer is worth the extra investment.
When you’re ready to take the next step, work with a trusted trailer dealer to get expert guidance and quality options. Utah Trailer Pros makes it simple by offering both utility and enclosed trailers, along with the support you need to make a confident purchase.
With a wide selection and expert guidance, Utah Trailer Pros makes it easy to find the trailer that’s the perfect fit.
FAQs
What is a utility trailer best used for?
A utility trailer is ideal for hauling equipment, building materials, or yard waste when you need open access and easy loading. Many landscapers, DIYers, and farmers prefer them for rugged tasks.
What are the advantages of an enclosed trailer?
Enclosed trailers protect cargo from weather and theft, ideal for valuable equipment, long-distance hauling, and organized storage. Contractors, movers, and motorsport enthusiasts often choose them for added security and versatility.
Do enclosed trailers require a stronger towing vehicle?
Yes. Enclosed trailers are heavier and usually need a vehicle with higher towing capacity. Always check your vehicle’s towing limits, since a mismatch can cause safety risks and make your transport less efficient.
How do I choose between a utility and an enclosed trailer?
Decide based on cargo type, frequency of use, and budget. Utility trailers cost less and load fast, while enclosed trailers provide weatherproof protection and secure storage.
Can I customize an enclosed trailer’s interior?
Yes. You can fit it with shelves, racks, or storage systems. These additional features make them useful if you need a mobile workshop or want organized, secure transport.